History
Hometown Atlantic Insurance Agency was founded on August 30, 1999 in an extra bedroom in Tracey’s apartment. During the agency’s almost 20 years in operation, it has grown steadily; that’s because our staff is dedicated to crafting policies that fit each individual clients’ needs at the most affordable price possible, all while providing friendly customer service.
We remained available to our clients in the wake of Hurricane Sandy, providing advice and guidance about whatever claims, coverage, or FEMA requirement information was needed. We continue to maintain this high level of dedication to our clients - we provide free insurance consultations, shop our existing clients around periodically and always keep our clients’ best interests at heart.
Tracey in front of her Long Beach home prior to the brunt of Hurricane Sandy.
Get in touch
We understand that finding an insurance policy that fits your needs and your budget isn’t always easy. That’s why we offer free insurance quotes.
Spanish Speaking Agents Available!
¡Se Habla Español!
Book an appointment!
Our Brokers
Founder/owner
Tracey Brennan
Tracey graduated from Quinnipiac University with a Bachelor’s degree in marketing in 1982. She has been working in the insurance industry in various offices since 1994, and finally decided to open her own office in August of 1999. Tracey is originally from Far Rockaway, but moved to Long Beach with her daughter in 1993. Since then, Tracey has dedicated herself to expanding her business practice by helping residents of Long Beach, Long Island & NY with their insurance needs.
broker
Grayson Donnellan
Grayson graduated from Johnson & Wales University with a Bachelor’s degree in 2014. He began working for Hometown Atlantic in March of 2015 and got his license in property and casualty insurance in 2016. Grayson focuses mainly on day-to-day operations such as quoting new and existing clients, policy maintenance and customer service matters.
broker
Alexandra Howley
Alexandra graduated from Hofstra University in 2014 with a Bachelor’s degree and from John Jay College in 2018 with a Master’s degree. She got her license in property and casualty insurance in early 2019, but has been working for Hometown Atlantic in various capacities since 2017. Alexandra focuses mainly on recruiting new business, bookkeeping, internet marketing strategies & special projects.